SECAM: “NO BLESSING FOR HOMOSEXUAL COUPLES IN ALL CHURCHES IN AFRICA”

SECAM: “No blessing for homosexual couples in all Churches in Africa”

Dear brothers and sisters in the Lord,

Grace and peace!

The message that I transmit to you today has received the agreement of His Holiness Pope Francis and His Eminence Cardinal Victor Manuel Fernández, prefect of the Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith.

It presents a consolidated summary of the positions adopted by various national and inter-territorial Episcopal Conferences across the African continent, in response to the publication of the Declaration of the Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith Fiducia supplicans of December 18, 2023. Within the Church Family of God in Africa, this Declaration has caused a shockwave, it has sown misconceptions and unrest in the minds of many lay faithful, consecrated persons and even pastors and aroused strong reactions.

The synthesis of responses of the African Episcopal Conferences highlights a common understanding and approach on their part. It encompasses their views on the unchanged doctrine of marriage within the Church, the pastoral care extended to all members of the Church and their unified position on same-sex unions.

1. Unchanged doctrine on marriage and sexuality

In their various messages, the Episcopal Conferences of the Church Family of God in Africa begin by reaffirming their unwavering attachment to the Successor of Peter, their communion with him and their fidelity to the Gospel. They recognize collectively that the Church’s doctrine on marriage and the family remains unchanged. They all noted the passages where Fiducia supplicans reaffirmed this traditional position of the Church and explicitly excluded the recognition of homosexual marriage. This position, rooted in the Holy Scriptures, has been taught without interruption by the universal Magisterium of the Church. Therefore, rites and prayers that could blur the definition of marriage – as an exclusive, stable and indissoluble union between a man and a woman, open to procreation – are considered as unacceptable. The distinction made by Fiducia supplicans between liturgical blessings or formal ritual blessings and spontaneous blessings is not intended to impose blessings for irregular couples and same-sex couples (cf. 31) even if the document says that they “should be carried out outside liturgical frameworks” (cf. 31 & 38).

2. Pastoral care and guidance

Through the declarations of the Episcopal Conferences, the Church in Africa, as the Family of God, reaffirms its commitment to continuing pastoral assistance to all its members. Clergy are encouraged to provide welcoming and supportive pastoral care, particularly to couples in irregular situations. The African bishops’ Conferences emphasize that people with homosexual tendency must be treated with respect and dignity, while reminding them that same-sex unions are contrary to the will of God and therefore cannot receive the blessing of the Church.

3. Position on homosexual unions and same-sex couples

The Episcopal Conferences generally prefer – each bishop remaining free in his diocese – not to offer blessings to same-sex couples. This decision stems from concern about potential confusion and scandal within the Church community. The constant teaching of the Church describes homosexual acts as “intrinsically disordered” (Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, Declaration Persona Humana, n. 8) and contrary to natural law. These acts, considered to exclude the gift of life and lacking true emotional and sexual complementarity, must not be approved under any circumstances (Catechism of the Catholic Church, n. 2357).

To support this position, a large majority of interventions by African bishops rely above all on the Word of God. They cite passages which condemn homosexuality, notably Lv 18:22-23 where homosexuality is explicitly prohibited and considered an abomination. This legislative text testifies to these practices in the environment of Israel, as well as other practices that God prohibits, such as infanticide (cf. The sacrifice of Isaac). An episcopal conference added the scandal of the homosexuals of Sodom (cf. Gen 19:4-11). In the text’s narration, homosexuality is so abominable that it will lead to the destruction of the city. In the New Testament, Saint Paul, in the Epistle to the Romans, also condemns what he calls unnatural relationships (cf. Rom 1:26-33) or infamous morals (cf. 1Co 6:9-10) . In addition to these biblical reasons, the cultural context in Africa, deeply rooted in natural law values regarding marriage and family, further complicates the acceptance of same-sex unions, as they are seen as contradictory to norms cultural and intrinsically bad.

      4. Concluding statement

In summary, the episcopal conferences across Africa, which have strongly reaffirmed their communion with Pope Francis, believe that the extra-liturgical blessings proposed in the Fiducia supplicans Declaration cannot be carried out in Africa without exposing themselves to scandals. . They remind, as Fiducia supplicans clearly does, to the clergy, religious communities, all believers and people of good will, that the doctrine of the Church on Christian marriage and sexuality remains unchanged. For this reason, we, African bishops, do not consider it appropriate for Africa to bless homosexual unions or same-sex couples because, in our context, this would cause confusion and be in direct contradiction to the cultural ethos African communities. The language of Fiducia supplicans remains too subtle for simple people to understand. Furthermore, it remains very difficult to convince that people of the same sex who live in a stable union do not claim the legitimacy of their own status.

We, African bishops, insist on the call to the conversion of all. Like Hosea, Jesus comes to bear witness to the tenderness of God: “He did not come to call the righteous, but sinners” (Mt 9:3). there is no doubt. But Jesus also extends his hand to the sinner so that he may rise, so that he may convert (cf. Mk 1:5). After having shown such tenderness for the adulterous woman, he said to her: “go now, sin no more” (Jn 8:11). As salt of the earth and light of the world (cf. Mt 5:13-14), the merciful mission of the Church is to go against the tide of the spirit of the world (cf. Rom 12:2) and to offer him the best, even if he is demanding.

Some countries prefer to have more time for the deepening of the Declaration which, in fact, offers the possibility of these blessings but does not impose them. In any case, we will still reflect on the value of the general theme of this document, beyond just blessings for couples in an irregular situation, that is to say on the richness of spontaneous blessings in popular pastoral care. .

       Grace and peace

“Grace and peace”: it is with these words taken from Saint Paul that in communion with His Holiness Pope Francis and all African bishops, as president of the Symposium of Episcopal Conferences of Africa and Madagascar (SECAM), I end this message thus calling on Christian communities not to let themselves be shaken. His Holiness Pope Francis, fiercely opposed to any form of cultural colonization in Africa, wholeheartedly blesses the African people and encourages them to remain faithful, as always, to the defense of Christian values.

Accra (Ghana), 11th January 2024 

Fridolin Cardinal Ambongo Besungu, ofm cap

President of SECAM